Top 10 Best Gourmet Peanut Butters in 2022

The 10 Best Gourmet Peanut Butter Reviews:

1. bNutty Gourmet Peanut Butter

bNutty Gourmet Peanut Butter

bNutty was started as an alternative to the candy and baked goods that were often used for fundraising for youth soccer. But selling it once a year wasn’t enough – customers loved it and begged to be able to buy it year–round.

From soccer fundraisers to farmer’s markets to national distribution, founder Joy Thompkins and her partner, Carol Podalak still ensure they provide ample opportunities for non-profit fund-raising and provide ongoing support for youth soccer in their community.

Highlighted Features:

  • MEET YOUR NEW FAVORITE FLAVORS: Gourmet peanut butter serves as the base for your next craving, whether it be something salty, sweet, or a bit more simple. Assorted flavors may vary (no duplicates)
  • SMALL-BATCHED ARTISAN GOODNESS: Natural peanut butter should be equally as delicious bite after bite, and this hand ground USA-made treat assures that high quality
  • A HEALTHIER INDULGENCE: With high quality ingredients, you’re getting only what’s on the label which includes a short list of honey roasted peanuts and other premium ingredients
  • IRRESISTIBLE PEANUT BUTTER FLAVORS: This gluten-free, all-natural snack is a healthy way to satisfy a craving with so many flavors to choose from. All of our flavors are gluten-free, and produced in a gluten-free facility. Flavors with pretzels, graham crackers, cookies, etc. all use a gluten-free version of those items.
  • WOMEN OWNED: BNutty was created by an American mom looking for a healthier alternative to baked goods for a family fundraiser. If for any reason you’re unsatisfied with any aspect of trying our gourmet peanut butter, please contact us within 30 days for a refund.

Buy on Amazon

2. Wonderspread Half-Calorie Gourmet Peanut Butter

Wonderspread Half-Calorie Gourmet Peanut Butter

Highlighted Features:

  • The world’s first True Half-Calorie Peanut Butter Spread: Gourmet flavor with only 100 Calories per 2 tablespoon serving (compared to peanut spreads with 200+ calories/2tbsp). Use as a protein spread with 6g protein/2tbsp serving.
  • Replaces Peanut Powder: Less calories per gram, and more flavor than powdered peanut butter or whipped peanut butter. No need to sacrifice flavor for better macros.
  • 1g Net Carbs: The ultimate keto combo of 1g Net Carbs (8g Carbs – 2g Fiber – 5g Allulose) and reduced calories.
  • No added sugar or palm oils: No unhealthy palm oils, bland low-quality protein fillers, or fibers that cause bloat.
  • Note on Calories: Calories are calculated using 0.4cals/g for Allulose, and 0cals/g for Fiber. Since this product contains no sugar, counting all 8g of carbs as normal Sugars or Starches at 4cals/g will result in an incorrect 132 calories/2tbsp.
  • Note on Texture: Product will be runny if shipped during hot weather, and firm if frozen. To restore creamy texture, either place in fridge for 15 minutes, or let it sit at a warm room temperature, and stir entire contents.

Buy on Amazon

3. BNutty Gourmet Peanut Butter

BNutty Gourmet Peanut Butter

bNutty was started as an alternative to the candy and baked goods that were often used for fundraising for youth soccer. But selling it once a year wasn’t enough – customers loved it and begged to be able to buy it year–round.

From soccer fundraisers to farmer’s markets to national distribution, founder Joy Thompkins and her partner, Carol Podalak still ensure they provide ample opportunities for non-profit fund-raising and provide ongoing support for youth soccer in their community.

Highlighted Features:

  • MEET YOUR NEW FAVORITE FLAVORs: Simply Salted Caramel features a creamy caramel ribbon and pink Himalayan salt swirled into our crunchy honey roasted peanut butter; Peacefully Plain Crunchy is made with honey roasted peanuts; Irresistible Pretzel is crafted with decadent honey roasted peanuts, white chocolate morsels, and savory pretzel bites
  • SMALL-BATCHED ARTISAN GOODNESS: Natural peanut butter should be equally as delicious bite after bite, and this hand ground USA-made treat assures that high quality
  • A HEALTHIER INDULGENCE: With high quality ingredients, you’re getting only what’s on the label which includes a short list of honey roasted peanuts and other premium ingredients
  • IRRESISTIBLE PEANUT BUTTER FLAVORS: This gluten-free, all-natural snack is a healthy way to satisfy a craving with so many flavors to choose from. All of our flavors are gluten-free, and produced in a gluten-free facility. Flavors with pretzels, graham crackers, cookies, etc. all use a gluten-free version of those items.
  • WOMEN OWNED: BNutty was created by an American mom looking for a healthier alternative to baked goods for a family fundraiser. If for any reason you’re unsatisfied with any aspect of trying our gourmet peanut butter, please contact us within 30 days for a refund

Buy on Amazon

4. The Peanut Principle Gourmet Nut Butter

The Peanut Principle Gourmet Nut Butter

The Peanut Principle Gourmet Nut Butter Company was started from the idea to blend our Chocolate and Confection Background with nut and seed butters.

All of our handcrafted butters are made with high-quality ingredients in small batches the old fashioned way. Try one of our homegrown flavors today and you will never see nut butter the same.

Highlighted Features:

  • South Carolina NON-GMO Dry Roasted Peanuts
  • Organic Sugar
  • NON-GMO Safflower Oil
  • Enjoy and taste the difference!

Buy on Amazon

5. Big Spoon Roasters Carrot Cake Almond & Walnut Butter

Big Spoon Roasters Carrot Cake Almond & Walnut Butter

We all love almond butter. It’s delicious, it’s multipurpose & it literally makes everything taste better: the ultimate comfort food!

But there’s a small problem: most nut butters (especially those grocery store nut butter packets) just don’t make the cut. They not only taste poor, they pack a ton of junk & artificial ingredients. We decided to change all of that & that’s how Big Spoon Roasters – a brand devoted to producing premium, craft nut butters – came to be.

We follow a simple line: the finest, natural ingredients; no junk; 100% transparency; small-batch production & exciting, unique flavors. It’s amazing how such clarity of thought can result in complex flavors, incredibly satisfying crunchy texture & second-to-none quality.

With quality, comes responsibility. At Big Spoon Roasters, we’ve always tried to match our standards of quality with responsible ways of doing business.

Every ingredient we use is not only premium in quality, it’s sourced ethically & sustainably as well. We partner exclusively with farms that use waste-free and green processes. Our employees are an integral part of our lives, and we take every measure to take good care of them.

Big Spoon Roasters is one happy family that does all it can to make an impact – through our products & through the way we work.

As a part of our little campaign, we pledge to donate 1% of all our sales to a variety of environmental charities that are striving to leave a greener, healthier home for our future generations.

Small steps, but they all matter. Here’s to enjoying the best that food has to offer: one spoonful at a time.

Highlighted Features:

  • FRESH, NATURAL, CREAMY ALMOND BUTTER: Every jar of Big Spoon Roasters Almond Butter packs the finest ingredients, unique coarse-ground texture, rich flavors & responsible production; All natural, pure almond butter
  • CERTIFIED POLLINATOR FRIENDLY ALMONDS: All almond butter flavors that leave our facility feature non-GMO bee friendly, PPO free, steam-pasteurized, heirloom Mission variety almonds sourced from responsible partner farms in California; No refined sugar, no palm oil
  • CLASSIC CARROT CAKE: Made with lightly toasted English walnuts, heirloom Mission almonds, cinnamon, nutmeg, allspice, maple syrup, and Jacobsen sea salt, Carrot Cake Almond & Walnut Butter is like decadent, spreadable carrot cake in a jar, but it’s vegan, paleo, and contains only heart-healthy fats
  • THE BEST INGREDIENTS, NO JUNK: We take great pride in using the best, all-natural ingredients out there with 100% transparency; No hidden junk, no additives; Gluten free, soy free, palm free, egg free almond nut butters
  • HANDCRAFTED, ARTISANAL, RESPONSIBLE: Our crunchy almond butters are handcrafted to order with great care & in small batches; 1% of all our sales is donated to various environmental charities; Click ‘Add to Cart’ to order right away

Buy on Amazon

6. Eliot’s Nut Butters Natural No Sugar Added Crunchy Peanut Butter

Eliot's Nut Butters Natural No Sugar Added Crunchy Peanut Butter

Just when you thought your PB couldn’t get any more tasty we’ve put this incredible flavor combo in just one jar. Whether enjoyed by the spoonful or spread generously on a piece of toast you won’t want to put the lid back on the jar.

The rich espresso flavor, savory chocolate undertones, and crunch from the nibs can’t be beat. We use top notch Organic, Fair-Trade Cacao Nibs from Theo Chocolate in Seattle.

The Espresso Beans are proudly sourced from a great local roaster, Happy Cup Coffee. Not only are their beans phenomenal but we are thrilled to partner with a local Portland company that empowers people with potential.

Highlighted Features:

  • High quality, minimal ingredients (5 total)!
  • Non-GMO peanuts, gluten-free. No artificial ingredients, colorings, and preservatives.
  • 100% Vegan. Small batch production filled with lots of TLC.
  • No added oils or stabilizers.
  • 72 grams of protein!

Buy on Amazon

7. Virginia Diner – Gourmet Natural Extra Large Butter

Virginia Diner - Gourmet Natural Extra Large Butter

Highlighted Features:

  • PREMIUM QUALITY – Our unique blister roasting process results in peanuts that are cooked to perfection in all-natural, Non-GMO oil, producing a uniquely delightful crunch.
  • ALL NATURAL – No Preservatives, No Cholesterol, No Trans Fats, Heart Healthy. Peanuts provide about 7 grams of powerful plant-based protein per serving and good sources of fiber, vitamins, and minerals.
  • FLAVOR PROFILE – Our premium crunchy  peanuts cooked in butter, sugar and salt to form a crunchy candy coating to satisfy any sweet tooth.
  • SUPER XL – These rare peanuts are all graded as “Super XL” which accounts for less than 2% of the total peanut crop. Since 1929 all of our peanuts have been harvested and roasted in the heart of Virginia peanut country.
  • GREAT GIFT- Our peanuts come packed in vacuum-sealed tins that reflect Virginia Diner heritage, making a great gift for loved ones at the holidays or any time of the year.
  • SMALL BATCH – You won’t find mass manufacturing with our sweet or savory treats. Each product is given the top care and attention to ensure you experience only the best.

Buy on Amazon

8. North Shore Goodies Original Coconut Peanut Butter

North Shore Goodies Original Coconut Peanut Butter

North Shore Goodies offers an assortment of delicious, all-natural peanut butters in different flavours sure to please everyone.

Originally introduced at a local Hawaiian farmer’s market, word spread quickly of the coconut peanut butter’s unique, delectable flavor and soft, creamy texture.

Free of any preservatives or chemicals, these unique peanut butters are SIMPLE, FRESH & DELICIOUS. Enjoy it yourself or treat the peanut butter lover in your life!

Highlighted Features:

  • All Natural Hawaiian Made, Grown on The Big Island of Hawai’i
  • Original Coconut Peanut Butter 2lb Jar
  • Simple Ingredients: Peanuts and Coconut – that’s it!
  • Free Priority Mail Shipping to all 50 US States!

Buy on Amazon

9. Peanut Butter Lovers T-Shirt Peanut Butter

Peanut Butter Lovers T-Shirt Peanut Butter

Highlighted Features:

  • Solid colors: 100% Cotton; Heather Grey: 90% Cotton, 10% Polyester; All Other Heathers: 50% Cotton, 50% Polyester
  • Imported
  • Machine Wash
  • Are you a peanut butter fiend? Tired of explaining to all of your friends and family members how much you love peanut butter? This I just freaking love peanut butter, okay? shirt is perfect for all you peanut butter lovers out there!
  • Funny peanut butter life tee shirt for moms and dads. Funny peanut butter lover shirt for birthday, Christmas, Father’s Day and Mother’s Day. Funny peanut butter kids back to school shirt for boys and girls.
  • Lightweight, Classic fit, Double-needle sleeve and bottom hem

Buy on Amazon

10. Mika & Sammy’s Gourmet Chicken Jerky Dog Treats

Mika & Sammy's Gourmet Chicken Jerky Dog Treats

Highlighted Features:

  • Made in the USA with Cage Free Chicken. American Sourced and American Made.
  • Grain & Gluten Free, NO Additives or Preservatives. No Fillers, By Product or Animal Meal.
  • Made with No More Than 3, 100% Human Grade Ingredients.
  • High in Protein.
  • Formulated for dogs of all ages and sizes.

Buy on Amazon

Last update on 2022-05-18 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API

Leave a Comment