The Comprehensive Cutco Knife Set Review: A Cut Above the Rest

You’ve probably had some sales reps knocking on your door trying to sell you a Cutco knife set. I’m pretty sure they could even have been your friends and relatives, as Cutco’s main method of selling involves sales reps marketing to their circle of influence first.

This is very clever seeing that people usually trust a brand that is recommended to them by friends and relatives.

But is a Cutco knife set really worth all the hype (not to mention the considerable investment)?

Cutco: The Story Behind the Knives That Cut Forever

Cutco is an American cutlery business that has been around since 1949. Based in Olean, New York, Cutco manufactures and distributes high-quality knives and other kitchen utensils. They boast of over 16 million sales to date.

One of Cutco’s strengths that sets them aside from every other cutlery manufacturer is what the company calls the Forever Guarantee.

With the Forever Guarantee, Cutco states that if you find your Cutco product unsatisfactory at any time — even years down the line — they will “make it right.”

Whether you are the original buyer or you got a Cutco knife set as a gift (even three generations down), Cutco promises to replace or sharpen your knives free of charge. Now that is a sweet deal everyone should get in on.

What gives Cutco the audacity to make such a daring promise? It’s quite simple, really. Cutco takes pride in their craft.

For the company, that means sourcing the best quality materials and using the best engineering practices. For you, it means paying a higher price. But at least you know your cutlery is covered — forever.

Your Cutco Knife Set Questions Answered

I know just from that brief introduction of Cutco, you already have some burning questions. I’m no psychic, but I know what you are wondering. Let’s get some answers to your questions, shall we?

Why are Cutco knife sets so expensive?

That’s a very good question with an equally good answer. The reason you’ll find that the Cutco knife set you so badly want to buy is so expensive is two-fold.

First, Cutco knives consist of premium-quality materials. Secondly, you pay a bit more to enable Cutco to fulfill their Forever Guarantee promise without running at a loss.

How good are Cutco knives?

Cutco knives are luxury cutlery. That alone says a lot about their quality — it’s a cut above the rest. Just to be clear, Cutco knives are very good.

How much should I expect to pay for a Cutco knife set?

A Cutco knife set is a considerable investment — they don’t come cheap. The cheapest sets will cost you about $200 to $300, while the large sets cost around $2,800 to $3,200.

Understanding Your Cutco Knife Set (and What Sets Them Apart from the Rest)

In order for you to make an informed decision before buying yourself a Cutco knife set, let’s quickly look at what makes for an excellent knife.

Make no mistake; although all knives may have a sharp edge (especially when new), not all knives are the same. So let’s see what sets your soon to be new Cutco knife set apart from the rest.

An ergonomic slip-resistant handle

Let’s start with the point of contact. One of the biggest factors that set a great knife apart from the average knife is the handle.

This is because the handle is not just your point of contact with the knife, but it is also the fulcrum upon which you exert the force required to cut. This then demands that the handle be very ergonomic.

This is the first place you will immediately notice the difference between a Cutco knife set and many other sets on the market.

Featuring a very durable thermo-resin material that is resistant to cracking, chipping, and breaking, these handles are engineered to last forever.

The material does not absorb water either, making it sanitary and hygienic. All this, while also offering a good solid grip on your knife.

Full tang blades

When it comes to picking the right knife for your kitchen, there are two things you need to look out for — the tang and the edge. Let’s talk tang for now.

When it comes to knives, you have two choices as far as tangs go: full and partial tang. A full tang means the knife has the metal that makes the blade going all the way to the end of the handle. A partial tanged knife, on the other hand, has the metal ending in the handle.

Every Cutco knife set, save table knives and cheese knives, are fully tanged knives. What are the advantages of fully tanged knives?

  • They are more solid and offer greater control
  • Stronger and more suited for heavy-duty use
  • Better balance due to the good weight distribution
  • Bolster gives your finger a smooth resting place

If you are looking for a new knife or a set, look for a full tanged knife. With a Cutco knife set, you are guaranteed all these advantages that come with full tanged knives.

Three rivets

Rivets are those pretty silver circles you see on the sides of a knife’s handle. Pretty as they are, they serve a greater purpose than just beautifying your knives. Rivets hold the blade and the handle together.

Cutco knives really shine here, literally. Featuring three nickel-silver rivets that are sanded flush with the handle, the knives are guaranteed to be durable and hygienic.

Razor-sharp blades

Of course, the main reason you need a knife is, well, cutting. That’s why a great knife has to feature a razor-sharp edge. And the blade must maintain that edge well.

Cutco knives have razor-sharp edges. And this is another area in which Cutco lives up to its Forever Guarantee. Made from high-carbon stainless steel, Cutco knives strike the perfect balance between a sharp edge and a durable edge. That’s why in this regard Cutco knives are definitely a cut above the rest.

How We Reviewed Each Cutco Knife Set (Without Getting Cut)

So how did we review these iconic knife sets? First, we looked at the construction of the knives, taking particular note of the materials used and the ergonomics of the knives.

Secondly, we considered the reviews of satisfied customers. After all, who else to give a realistic picture of how these knives fit in with your dinner preparation and eating.

The Cutco Knife Set Review: 4 Awesome Sets to Consider

Ready to get yourself a new Cutco knife set? Whether you are just starting out or whether you’re revamping your kitchen, you’ll definitely find a Cutco knife set to suit your needs here.

Let’s get to it, shall we?

1. Cutco (Model 1864): 4-piece table knife set

Cutco Table Knives Set of Four with Tray, Four of Cutcos Best-Selling...
  • Four of Cutcos best knife in a dishwasher safe tray. Cut everything on your plate and slice through even the thickest...
  • Use the Table Knife once and you won't need to ask why it's our best-selling knife. Praised by our customers for being...
  • The Table Knife is an ideal choice even if steak isn't on the menu, cut salads, spread butter and more with this long...

If you are looking for a gorgeous set of table knives to accompany your equally gorgeous cutlery, the Cutco 4-piece table knife set is it. This Cutco knife set is ideal for a small family or simply to help you boost your current collection of cutlery.

The handles on these knives are very ergonomic, durable, and easy to clean. As for the blades, they are sharp enough to cut through a steak but can also easily spread butter on your bread.

This is one of the most popular Cutco knife sets, as its 5 out of 5 star Amazon customer rating proves. The $160 to $175 price tag may be a bit steep for a set of four table knives, but it certainly is worth it.

2. Homemaker +8 Set (with block and petite chef’s knife)

No products found.

If you are looking to go all out and get a large set of Cutco knives, then the Homemaker +8 Set is worth considering. This Cutco knife set also makes for a housewarming gift that no one will forget.

This Cutco knife set is a best-seller for one simple reason: It is probably the only set you’ll ever buy. The Homemaker +8 comes with 18 pieces of cutlery and a gorgeous block for safe storage.

This is definitely one set of knives that literally makes the cut both in the kitchen and on the table. And that’s because the set includes cutlery for both places. Included in this particular set are 10 must-have specialty knives and 8 table knives.

The specialty knives include:

  • 2-3/4-inch paring knife
  • Trimmer
  • Spatula spreader
  • Turning fork
  • 6-3/4-inch petite carver
  • Butcher knife
  • Carving fork
  • 9-inch carver
  • 9-3/4-inch slicer
  • 7-5/8-inch petite chef knife

The Homemaker +8 will definitely get your kitchen fully functional without the need for any other knives. And it will keep it functioning well, thanks to the knife sharpener that also comes as part of the package.

As with all Cutco knives, the Homemaker +8 features premium materials and precision engineering, making for a spectacular knife set.

This Cutco knife set has an Amazon customer rating of 4.9 out of 5 stars. It is definitely worth the $1,200 to $1,350 premium it commands. After all, it does come with the Forever Guarantee.

3. Cutco Ultimate Set (with block)

If you love entertaining, then there’s only one Cutco knife set for you: the Cutco Ultimate Set. Cutco’s Ultimate Set is a fabulous collection of knives that looks stunning on the countertop or on the dinner table next to your dinnerware.

The entire range of Cutco’s kitchen knives and 12 table knives make up the massive 32-piece Ultimate Set. 

For those large meals, this cutlery set will enable you to prep your food fast and easy, leaving you with more time to do the core task of the day — entertaining. That full range, apart from the table knives, includes:

  • 2-3/4-inch paring knife
  • Trimmer
  • Spatula spreader
  • Turning fork
  • 6-3/4-inch petite carver
  • Butcher knife
  • Carving fork
  • 9-inch carver
  • 9-3/4-inch slicer
  • 7-5/8-inch petite chef knife
  • 9-1/4 –inch French chef knife
  • 7-inch Santoku knife
  • Vegetable knife
  • Cleaver
  • Hardy slicer
  • Boning knife
  • Salmon knife
  • Super shears
  • Traditional cheese knife

The name says it all — this is the ultimate collection of knives and possibly the only one you’ll ever need. Top it all off with a block that has either a honey or cherry finish, and you have a super knife set with a 5.0 out of 5 stars customer rating.

But quality and luxury of this caliber don’t come cheap. This Cutco knife set will cut a deep hole in your pocket with a price tag of $2,600 to $3,100.

4. Cutco 3-piece knife and sheath set

Perhaps your kitchen doesn’t need a large Cutco knife set. Perhaps it simply needs a smaller set to start off your cutlery collection or to beef it up.

If that is so, then look no further than the Cutco 3-Pc. Knife and Sheath set.

This superb set of Cutco knives comes with:

  • Four-inch paring knife
  • Trimmer
  • 7-5/8-inch petite chef

One of the best features that come with these three knives, besides superb functionality, of course, is that this set comes with protective sheaths.

These ensure safe storage of the knives so that nothing damages them — and it keeps them from causing damage. 

The sheaths also make it easy to move around with the knives. This means you can take your favorite Cutco knife set with you on a picnic, or barbeque, or any other outings where you would love the pleasure of having your favorite knives with you.

Every kitchen should definitely feature this Cutco knife set; it’s just that good. Perhaps that’s why it has earned an excellent 4.9 out 5 stars rating for itself.

For $250 to $320, you get yourself a great start to a professional kitchen, or a boost, depending on what you’re looking for.

Cutco Knife Sets: Cutting Down the Competition

Having looked at these four examples of what Cutco has to offer in terms of knife sets, let’s see how it fares against some other cutting-edge knife sets available.

Cutco vs. J.A. Henckel

J.A. Henckel, formerly Zwilling (twins in German) is another brand that produces world-class knife sets. They use some of the best materials, just like Cutco, and take precision engineering seriously. Take, for example, J.A. Henckels 18-Piece Knife Block Set.

ZWILLING Professional S 18-pc Kitchen Knife Set with Block, Chef’s...
  • SET INCLUDES: 2.75-inch birds beak peeling, 2.75-inch trimming, 4-inch purer, 5-inch serrated utility, 5-inch santorum,...
  • RESILIENT BLADES: Ice-hardened FRIODUR blade starts sharper stays sharper longer and has superior resilience
  • BALANCED KNIVES: Ergonomic polymer three rivet handles are perfectly bonded to the full tang

The 18-piece J.A. Henckel’s set of knives is superb, especially since it comes with a tantalizing $550 to $650 price tag. This set has not yet been rated on Amazon.

While it comes with the same superior craftsmanship as Cutco’s sets, it doesn’t come with a Forever Guarantee, which is a hard act to follow. But, the J.A. Henckels knife set does have an edge over its Cutco counterpart, as it’s cheaper.

Cutco vs. Wusthof

Another cutlery brand that many professional cooks swear by is Wusthof. And small wonder, as Wusthof does make exceptionally good knives that strike the perfect balance between utility and beauty. Again, the biggest disadvantage that Cutco knife sets have here is their restrictive price tags.

A great example of a Wusthof knife set is the 4 out of 5 stars rated Wusthof Classic 8-piece knife set (with a block). This set costs just $350 to $450.

As to which set to choose out of the two, it probably all boils down to whether you prefer serrated blades (Cutco) or straight edge blades (Wusthof).

However, if you would love the peace of mind of knowing that you will never need to replace your knife set, ever, Cutco is the way to go. If you’re looking for a knife set, period, then the Wusthof will serve you just fine.

3. Cutco vs. Victorinox

When pitted against the Victorinox, many people will side with Victorinox. This is again because of the price. When it comes to quality, Victorinox does hold its own in the cutlery world and strikes a good balance between quality and price.

Victorinox Swiss Classic 18-piece Knife Block Set
  • Set includes 4-inch Paring Knife, 4-inch Serrated Paring Knife, 4.5-inch Tomato/Serrated Utility Knife, 5-inch...
  • No empty slots in the knife block; this is a complete set with everything you need for your kitchen cutting, slicing and...
  • NSF certified knives are professional grade and are made to the highest sanitary standards

Take the 5 out of 5 stars rated Victorinox Swiss Classic 18-piece knife block set. At $250 to $350, this knife set is a steal. It, like the Cutco knife sets, also comes with serrated blades and a lifetime warranty, but at a better price. I guess the Victorinox takes this round.

The Perfect Cutco Knife Set for You, Your Kitchen, and Your Table

So you’re just in love with Cutco and would like to the live the American dream with an American-made set of knives. Cutco is a great brand, after all.

But which Cutco knife set should you buy? The Homemaker +8 Set is a great choice for most families. However, if you love wowing guests with your cooking and cutlery, then go for the Ultimate Set.

So go ahead, pick your favorite Cutco knife set, and let’s get cooking.

Last update on 2022-05-18 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API

Leave a Comment