Cutco Steak Knives Review

Cutco is fast becoming a trustworthy name in the knife business and the Cutco steak knives have aptly highlighted the prowess of this exceptional brand. But does the blade meet the hype?

Today we are going to consider the design and ongoing performance of these knives and compare them to other leading blades in the industry in order to provide you with a cohesive picture of what is available in the realm of knife purchases. 

What Are Cutco Steak Knives?

Cutco steak knives are a growing branch of the exceptional Cutco knife industry. As a brand Cutco has focused on producing knives that consider quality at the top of all aspects of production.

These blades are not cheap but do constitute lasting cutlery implementations for consumers interested in a sturdy knife that stays sharp for years to come.

They are not the most ornate knives and their ubiquitous enamel handles seem to permeate every product they have, but to many, this is just a sign of sturdy craftsmanship and high standards.

Product Specs  

Cutco knives are made from stainless 440A stainless steel and built to last. They are troubling to maintain but with a warranty as comprehensive as Cutco, their Cutco steak knives could be the last steak knives you ever purchase.

The Cutco steak knives are typically serrated, which improves their longevity but impairs or even prevents your ability to sharpen them in the future.

They are relatively small, easy to handle, and no-nonsense when it comes to usage. Cutco steak knives are certainly great, but are they the greatest?

Pricing  

This is a huge sticking point for Cutco steak knives and can put a stop to your research right here if you are not prepared to shell out a lot of cash to own a set.

For a set of 4, expect to pay something in the realm of $200. It is important to note that with this purchase; you are not just paying for a blade, you are paying for a rigorously endorsed lifetime warranty, a business supported in and by American labor, and a blade that is comprehensively sturdy.

The price is not a rip-off, but for what the product is, are people ready or even able to put that much money down on a set of knives?

How It Compares

There is no way to know the true cost of these knives without considering what their competition is. To that end, we have compiled a list of other leading knife producers and compared them to Cutco steak knives on the grounds of price, warranty, and quality. These other steak knife producers include:

Wusthof Gourmet Six Piece Steak Knife Set

Shun Steak-Knife Set

ZWILLING J.A. Henckels TWIN Signature 11-pc Knife Block Set

Cutco 1865 4-Pc. Table Knife Set

CUTCO #1865 Set of 4 Classic Brown Model 1759 Table Knives in Gift Box
  • CUTCO Forever Guarantee provides for free sharpening and replacement forever.
  • Highly engineered thermo-resin ergonomic handles will not crack, chip, fade or absorb material
  • Manufactured in the USA by American craftworkers (leather sheath from Mexico)

Price

Right out of the gate, Cutco and their Cutco steak knives stand out, but is the cost worth the quality? These blades will keep their edges for years to come and when they do not, the lifetime warranty kicks in and you get yourself a brand new blade.

For steak eaters who want to make one purchase they will be proud of, the Cutco knives are a great a lasting choice you won’t be disappointed you made.

So if you can afford this knife, there’s a good chance you can make your money back just on the warranty alone.

Build Quality

These knives keep their edge, the steel runs the length of the handle and the production is America-centered from start to finish.

The only real issue is that Cutco knives are not really designed to be sharpened, which can be a sticking point for knife enthusiasts who appreciate caring for their knives as much as using them.

Additionally, the handles can be a little tricky to work with and are not always the prettiest to look at.

Warranty

This is where Cutco steak knives really shine; the lifetime warranty is not only comprehensive, it is always rigorously encouraged and managed by Cutco.

Drop your knife in the disposal, damage it during cooking, dull it through years of wear and tear; regardless of what you put these knives through, Cutco is here to make sure you are always in supply of sturdy Cutco knives once your first purchase is made.  

Pros

  • Unbeatable warranty
  • Lasting and durable blades
  • Variety of choices so you can own a complete set

Cons

  • Expensive
  • Difficult to sharpen
  • Not focused on aesthetic first

Wusthof Gourmet Six Piece Steak Knife Set

Wusthof Gourmet Six 6-Piece German Precise Laser Cut High Carbon...
  • WÜSTHOF GOURMET SERIES – 6 Piece Steak Knife Set with triple riveted synthetic polypropylene handles that resist...
  • RAZOR SHARP – High Carbon Stainless Steel Blades, precisely cut with the latest state of the art technology for...
  • WÜSTHOF STEAK KNIFE SET – Includes six 4 1/2" Steak Knives. Ergonomic handle design made from a long-lasting...

German engineering has been a triumphant benchmark for their exceptional culture and an ongoing trope for German products and production the world over.

Wusthof is no exception to the rule and manages to expand on steak knives by cultivating a line of laser cut blades from a formidable stainless steel alloy.

The durable polypropylene handles are riveted directly to the steel so you can expect this item to be durable through a wide variety of uses and implementations.

Finally, these dishwasher-friendly knives are ergonomically designed so you can comfortably cut through any steak meal that comes your way.

Price

I hope you are sitting down: owning Wursthof steak knives can be as affordable as around $100 for a set of 6.

You will be missing out on the warranty and lasting craftsmanship of the Cutco steak knives, but at the price and for the product, Wursthof is a very challenging brand to beat.

This set also features 6 knives (compared to just 4 Cutco knives) and includes more ornamental packaging.

Build Quality

They will not quite last the lifetime of the Cutco steak knives, but the German engineering and laser-focused quality ensure that this is a purchase you will be proud you made.

Some reviews note they are more prone to dulling and can sometimes rust if you are not careful, but for knife enthusiasts, this should be no problem.

Additionally, the larger design might be too big for some users, but this is likely to even out as others might appreciate the larger design.

Warranty

They are not notoriously bad in a normal sense but juxtaposed to the other sturdy warranties on this list, Wursthof does not stand out as a leader in any respect.

Expect to be covered for factory defects, extenuating circumstances, and otherwise little else with regard to this set of knives.

Meanwhile, with no listed access to ongoing sharpening resources, Wusthof pales in comparison to Cutco and other knife makers.

Pros

  • Affordable
  • Ergonomic design
  • Good reviews

Cons

  • Less than thrilling warranty
  • Not made in the United States
  • Blades can be prone to dulling

Shun Steak-Knife Set

Shun DMS-400 Classic 4-Piece Knife Set Enhance Dinners with Elegant,...
  • Make every steak dinner more enjoyable with these razor-sharp steak knives; Shun’s fine-edged Classic Steak Knives...
  • These handsome steak knives perform with precision and enhance any table setting; add elegance to dinner parties,...
  • Handcrafted in Japan, these knives feature premium VG-MAX blade steel with 68 micro-layers of Damascus cladding; blades...

Shun is a strong force for steak knife development known the world over and their stunning steak knife set will not only turn heads but slice steak without consequence or struggle.

These sleek blades are comprised of a 33 layer, 5-inch, non-serrated blade precision-forged by KAI who continues to lead blade manufacturing in Japan and across the globe.

The gorgeous pakkawood handles are an elegant homage to Chinese blades over centuries of implementation and the resulting knife is a comfortable and stunning semblance of engineering and design.

Price

At over $300 for a set, this is definitely the most expensive of our list. With the cost, you are buying design and quality, but if this is a prohibitor, you may be one to consider other knife options.

The warranty is also nowhere near as comprehensive as Cutco’s, which is likely to be a problem with consumers who may have already been reluctant to shell out so much cash for just one product.

Build Quality

This is definitely what you are paying for. The construction of these knives is sturdy, the design is exceptional, and the final product is a beautiful testament to quality in cutlery.

There is really no other knife on our list quite as exquisite or fun to look at as these; for knife enthusiasts, this is really top of the line knife-making and certainly a favorite on our list.

Warranty

Any warranty claim is managed according to the sellers of Shun knives although they do offer free lifetime sharpening. This does give it a bit of friction for consumers who enjoyed Cutco’s lifetime services.

They are very sturdy knives though so with any luck you may never have to call for any kind of warranty, anyway.

Pros

  • Beautiful knives
  • Free lifetime sharpening
  • Very durable and strong

Cons

  • Expensive
  • Warranty is unreliable
  • May be out of place in terms of style for most kitchens

ZWILLING J.A. Henckels TWIN Signature 11-pc Knife Block Set

ZWILLING Twin Signature 11-pc Knife Block Set, Chef Knife, Bread...
  • SET INCLUDES: 2.75-inch bird's beak peeling, 4 inches paring, 5-inches serrated utility, 6-inch utility, 7-inch hollow...
  • RESILIENT BLADE: Ice-hardened FRIODUR blade starts sharper, stays sharper longer and has superior resilience
  • PRECISE CUTTING: Precision honed blade and laser-controlled edge ensures ideal cutting angle for sharpness and...

Zwilling is a quality knife brand with a reputation for excellence that is not often shared with other blade makers.

In this set, you will find a hollow-edge santoku, a utility knife, serrated utility knife, a paring knife, a bread cutter, and a peeler. In addition, it also includes a 4 ½ inch steak knife, scissors, and a block to store them in.

Overall, the style and design are minimal but the resulting product is excellent. The handle is made of polymer so it is sturdy and durable. Meanwhile, the blades are made of high-carbon stainless-steel and keep their edge for many uses to come.

Price

At over $250, this set is not distinctly cheap, but since you are getting much more than just 4-6 steak knives as compared to other options on our list, you might just be getting more bang for your buck in this deal.

The quality is good and the range of options make this purchase well worth your consideration.  The included knives are not garbage either and should make any owner feel confident that this purchase was worth the cost.

Build Quality

These durable, ice-hardened blades make a for a lasting and fine-looking addition to any kitchen. They are not the outright champion of this list, but they are great to work with and fun to look at.

Purchasers have noted that the blades are somewhat thin, which can create usage problems, but overall this has not overshadowed their quality.

Meanwhile, this quality consistency seems to extend across all the knives featured in this set, so you should feel secure across all of your kitchen activities when you purchase from Zwilling.

Warranty

You are covered for factory defects for life, but no sharpening, no replacement strategy, and nothing for even breakage during normal usage.

This really is a brand focused primarily on selling these knives and not on keeping a lasting customer relationship.

Cutco steak knives, as is apparent on this list, truly have set the bar for a customer-centric approach to their business model.

Pros

  • Lightweight and easy to use
  • Very sharp compared to competitors
  • Durable ice-hardened design

Cons

  • Warranty is limited
  • Thin blades
  • Knife block has issues with holding other blades

Conclusion

Cutco continues to be a brand steeped in quality and customer care. They are quality knives that are meant to last a lifetime and to instill confidence in the brand’s ongoing support of their customer base.

Their lifetime warranty coupled with the sturdy design of their knives make this a great purchase for knife enthusiasts and general users alike.

The guaranteed free sharpening for life also assures confidence and convenience in their exceptional blades. Having said that, these are an expensive knife and for many, the juice might not be worth the squeeze so to speak.

We are proud to rate this product four out of five stars, noting that the quality of the knives is good but not as pristine as the price might allude.

However, with a top-notch warranty, this might well be the last knife set you ever purchase and one you are proud to own.

Last update on 2022-05-18 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API

Leave a Comment